Castaways |1500 N High StLancasterOH43130 | (740) 654-9197
1500 N High St
LancasterOH 43130
 (740) 654-9197
Open for Carry Out & Dine-InSteak • Pizza • Fresh Oysters • Seafood
The entire Castaways menu is available for carry-out!
View Our Menu
item imageSteak
item imageFresh Oysters
item imagePizza & More

Restaurant Lancaster, OH

Heartwarming meals at an attractive price with friendly service and in a comfortable setting await when you visit Castaways.


Comfort Food | Cozy Atmosphere | Healthy Options

For more than 70 years, our American restaurant in Lancaster, OH, has been the go-to place in Lancaster when you're looking for a wide variety of delicious meals in a cozy and quaint setting. Our menu is full of time-tested favorites to please every member of the family. We source our freshly-butchered meats locally from Bay Food Market to ensure your meal is as fresh as it can possibly get. 

Would you like to enjoy your dinner during the nice weather? You can also dine on our outdoor patio for an even more pleasurable meal. And if you want to enjoy a fun time with a party or corporate outing? We'll open our restaurant during non-business hours and give your company our entire attention for an outstanding gathering.

You will not want to miss out on our Prime Rib Wednesday. To get your Prime Rib, you must pre-order on Tuesday nights. 

Our Menu:

  • Center cut ham steak
  • Filet mignon
  • Fried haddock
  • Fried shrimp
  • Grilled chicken breasts
  • New York strip steak
  • Oysters
  • Pork tenderloin
  • Porterhouse steak
  • Salads
  • Sandwiches
  • Stone-baked pizzas
  • Twin lobster tails . . . and more
  • Our entire menu is available for carryout

What Our Customers Are Saying:

"Food is always good! Patio was a very nice area for a large group. We were there on Wednesday for Prime Rib—-wonderful." -- Daryl B.

"Best locally-owned restaurant we have EVER had the pleasure of eating at! Freshest meat I've ever put in my mouth. Best pizza ever and great steaks! I loved the atmosphere and the smell of food cooking throughout the entire place." -- Jessica L.

Contact Us

Don't wait any longer to experience the local freshness and friendly hospitality. Make a visit today to Castaways. Call us at (740) 654-9197 with questions or to order carryout. We look forward to seeing you.


Contact Us

More Details:

More Details about Castaways

Accepted Payment Methods:

  • Debit Card

Business Hours:

Business Hours:

Tuesday 4:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Wednesday 4:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Thursday 4:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Friday 4:00 PM – 9:30 PM
Saturday 4:00 PM – 9:30 PM

Closed Sunday & Monday